Return-Path: <nifl-povracelit@literacy.nifl.gov> Received: from literacy (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by literacy.nifl.gov (8.10.2/8.10.2) with SMTP id h9GILqV22542; Thu, 16 Oct 2003 14:21:52 -0400 (EDT) Date: Thu, 16 Oct 2003 14:21:52 -0400 (EDT) Message-Id: <3F8EE149.8050100@georgetown.edu> Errors-To: listowner@literacy.nifl.gov Reply-To: nifl-povracelit@literacy.nifl.gov Originator: nifl-povracelit@literacy.nifl.gov Sender: nifl-povracelit@literacy.nifl.gov Precedence: bulk From: Albert Wat <ayw@georgetown.edu> To: Multiple recipients of list <nifl-povracelit@literacy.nifl.gov> Subject: [NIFL-POVRACELIT:1255] Re: Article on Closing the Achievement gap X-Listprocessor-Version: 6.0c -- ListProcessor by Anastasios Kotsikonas Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed Status: O Content-Length: 21410 Lines: 377 Hello, This was a very provocative article. Thanks for sending it to the listserv! I wish I have more time to write a more well thought-out response, but I feel compelled to respond to some of the ideas presented in the article. I appreciate the author asking schools to be more deliberate about their beliefs about the achievement gap in their particular institutions and avoiding generalizations about all students of color. I agree that in addressing this problem, it's important not to stereotype students of color. I also appreciate the concept that "achievement" as referred to in this gap is very narrowly defined and that there are other measurements of achievement that we as a society and even educators pay less attention to. However, to call it a "sound bite" belittles the problem that the gap presents not only to communities of color, but to all communities. Yes, there are other measurements of achievements, but I don't think we can afford to have one segment of our society excel in "keeping a connection to family, being happy, learning about other cultures" and maintaing a balance in their lives and another segment excelling in academics, tests, and careers. I'm all for redefining achievement or success in our society, but that doesn't mean there's no academic achievement gap, or that it doesn't matter. One benefit of the recent emphasis on achievement gap could be that it forces us to question the allocation of resources in our schools, education systems and communities. If we treat these discrepancies with less concern, I'm afraid that this potential benefit will not be realized. Finally, it's interesting that the author is coming from the perspective of independent schools. I wonder if she would have the same message for public (especially urban) schools. -- Albert Wat, Program Director DC Schools Project Office of Volunteer & Public Service - Center for Social Justice Georgetown University, Poulton Hall 1421 37th St., NW, 1st Floor Washington, DC 20057 Tel: (202)687-8868 Fax: (202)687-8980 https://data.georgetown.edu/outreach/csj/service/programs/dcsp/ Mary Ann Corley wrote: >Closing the Achievement Gap? Five Questions Every School Should Ask > >By Patricia Romney > >Mention the problem of the achievement gap between white students and >students of color and educators will likely respond with nods, sighs of >agreement, and looks of frustration. Yet are we clear about what we mean >when we speak about an "achievement gap"? Can we identify our specific >concerns about academic achievement among black and Latino students? Do we >consider the implications of naming and framing these concerns in the >language of an achievement gap? A reported disparity in school achievement >between white students and black and Latino students has captured a great >deal of attention in recent years. The perception of an "achievement gap" is >supported by some hard data that documents differences in grades, test >scores, and courses taken. Jenks and Phillips, in their book The Black-White >Test Score Gap (The Brookings Institution, 1998), for example, wrote that >"blacks scored below three- quarters of their white counterparts on a whole >range of standardized tests." Though differences in student performance by >race narrowed in the years after Brown v. Board of Education, in its March >12, 2000 issue, Education Week reported that the gains made by black >students between 1970 and the 1990s have come to a halt. > >Research and writing about the reported achievement gap (Williams, ed., >1996; Johnson, 2002; Chubb and Loveless, eds., 2002; Freeman, Freeman, and >Mercuri 2002) is ongoing and examines potential causes as wide ranging and >complex as the roles of poverty, peer pressure, parenting, teacher quality, >inadequate school resources, television, test bias, and genetics. >Interventions to close the gap range from curricular reform, raising teacher >expectations, smaller classroom sizes, and imitation of successful schools. > >As with most sound-bites, however, the reality of the "achievement gap" >assertion is rarely questioned. In 1999, my colleagues and I completed a >study of achievement among black and Latino high school students in a high >achieving independent school, and our research led us to question the >concept. After analyzing survey data from students and alumni and conducting >interviews and focus groups with students, faculty, administrators, alumni, >and parents, several questions arose for us that we believe are crucial for >all schools to consider. > >ARE YOU SURE THERE IS AN ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE GAP IN YOUR SCHOOL? > >Because there is a reported achievement gap does not mean that one >necessarily exists in your school. In our study, black and Latino >grade-point averages were comparable to those of white and Asian-American >students. There was no statistically significant difference in grade-point >averages between the racial and ethnic groups. > >RATHER THAN FOCUSING ON THE "ACHIEVEMENT GAP," SCHOOLS MIGHT BETTER ASK, >"What is the spirit of learning and the climate for learning in our school?" > >When we share this information with the faculty of independent schools, many >of them quickly shift gears. They respond: "Well, what about advanced >courses? Black and Latino students aren't taking enough of them. They are >not challenging themselves." > >There may, indeed, be an under-representation of black and Latino students >in advanced classes in your school, but make sure you carefully examine the >data. Sometimes the small numbers of students of color in a school skew our >perceptions. In many independent schools, black and Latino students >represent less than 10 percent of the student body. With a percentage this >small, the perceived absence of black and Latino students from upper-level >classes may be an artifact of scarcity, not underachievement. > >If you still think there is a performance gap in your school - find out >where. Be specific. Look at the numbers. Look at margins of error. Know >where the gaps are. Are they in standardized test scores, grade-point >averages, participation in honors courses, numbers of students who graduate >with honors? We live in a world of myth and perception. If you buy blindly >into the idea of an achievement gap, you may create or reinforce the >"reality" you fear. > >HOW DO YOU DEFINE ACHIEVEMENT? > >Achievement is usually defined in terms of a particular type of learning >outcome, specifically performance on tests and grades achieved in courses >taken. In our study, we found that black and Latino students defined >achievement in a more complex and comprehensive way than their peers. As >with other students, college and career mattered to students of color, but >other desired outcomes were also named. In addition to academic success, >black and Latino students in the study stressed the importance of making a >contribution to their communities, keeping a connection to family, being >happy, and learning about other cultures. They were less likely than their >white and Asian-American classmates to stress high income or Ivy League >colleges as desired outcomes, preferring instead to maintain a balance in >their lives. > >Our research revealed that black and Latino students particularly focused on >the tugs between pressure to achieve and other cultural interests and needs, >like relating to family and maintaining friendships. Black students were >more likely than their peers to say that they set limits on study time so as >to maintain some free time as a way of coping with the potential negative >effects of pressure and stress. > >Black and Latino students were also more likely to mention the goal of >happiness than were white and Asian-American students (32 percent vs. 0 >percent). In addition, they were more likely to report that they wanted to >return to, and help, their racial or ethnic communities than were their >white peers (25 percent vs. 0 percent). Conversely, white students were more >likely than black and Latino students to mention goals of fame or respect >(38 percent vs. 4 percent). > >The words of one black student epitomize this perspective: "I want to be >like my parents.... It's weird - when you come to (this school)... everybody >wants to be an engineer... make millions of dollars ...I don't want to be a >millionaire. I wouldn't mind having a normal job, waking up every morning, >taking a train into the city, coming home, cooking dinner for my family, >checking (my kids') homework. I don't want to have a job...where I can't >spend time with my family." > >While students from all groups mentioned the value of diversity, as compared >to white students, black, Latino, and Asian-American students valued and >placed greater emphasis on the learning that came from studying and living >with a diverse student body. They often mentioned how much they appreciated >social interaction with students of different backgrounds, and they >emphasized the merits of learning about different cultures. They valued >diversity both for its intrinsic worth and because they believed the >multicultural competence they acquired at their school would contribute to >their ability to perform well in their future work lives. > >Latino students were likely to mention their school's diversity (86 >percent), even more frequently than they praised courses, educational >opportunities, and school activities (57 percent). One Latino male noted, >"You don't just learn from books and from textbooks. You learn from >experience.... You learn how to get along with people or how to negotiate, >compromise.... This school gives you that, too." Latino (86 percent) and >black students (43 percent) praised their school's training in diversity >more frequently than white or Asian-American students (38 percent; 29 >percent). > >As one African-American girl stated: "I am able to mingle with different >ethnic groups and different cultures and lifestyles.... You get people here >from all different countries and you have to learn how to share with people; >you can't just be like, 'well I want to do this because it's my way.'" > >The same trend appeared in the results of our research with the school's >alumni. Black and Latino alumni more than white alumni in our study stated >that they believed their attendance at the independent school had helped >them to work with people of diverse backgrounds, to work cooperatively, and >to adapt to change. > >In sum, black and Latino students offer us the opportunity to redefine the >parameters of the purported achievement gap, expanding the notion of >achievement beyond high grades and admission to Ivy League colleges to >include attention to family, service to community, an appreciation of >intercultural learning, and the pursuit of happiness without trade-offs in >academic excellence. > >WHAT IMPACT DOES THE IDEA OF AN ACHIEVEMENT GAP HAVE ON THE PERFORMANCE OF >BLACK AND LATINO STUDENTS IN YOUR SCHOOL? > >Independent schools can benefit by asking: "Are there differences in how >diverse populations at my school define achievement? Whose definitions of >achievement does the school promote?" > >The history of reported findings of cognitive and social deficits among >people of color is long. From the 19th century, when skulls were measured in >the vain hope of uncovering essential differences in intelligence by race, >to the research of Shockley during the middle of the 20th century, to the >Bell Curve theories of the 1990s, and the current emphasis on the >"achievement gap" (sometimes even called an "academic gulf"), attributions >of lower intelligence persist, particularly with regard to assumptions about >black intelligence. Discussion of these presumed deficits still dominates >our social discourse in schools, as well as at the national level. > >Is it possible that preoccupation with what Michael Cole and Jerome Bruner >(1972) have called "the deficit hypothesis" contributes to underperformance >among students of color? According to psychologist Claude Steele (1998): >"The finger-pointing debate over the underperformance of black >undergraduates has missed one big culprit - 'stereotype threat.' This is the >threat of being viewed through the lens of a negative stereotype, or the >fear of doing something that would inadvertently confirm that stereotype" >(p. 46). Stereotype threat, as described by Steele, is "a threat in the air >that can affect any group about whom a negative stereotype exists...if the >threat is experienced in the midst of a domain performance - classroom >presentation or test-taking, for example - the emotional reaction it causes >could directly interfere with performance" (p. 204). Does the repeated >assertion of an achievement gap constitute a stereotype threat undermining >the performance of students of color while striving to improve it? > >Speaking of women's education, Belenky et al. (1996) make clear that >teaching styles can empower or cripple students. They assert "every >woman,regardless of age, social class, ethnicity, and academic achievement, >needs to know that she is capable of intelligent thought, and she needs to >know it right away" (p. 193). > >Negative assessments directed toward the intellectual capabilities of people >of color have had a similar dampening effect on the achievement of black and >Latino students, who are described as underachieving and lacking in academic >ability. Historically, the result is students who feel diminished. > >Taking into account the effect of this negative perception, one could say >that the so-called "achievement gap" is maintained by a vicious cycle. >Describing children who are scapegoated in their families, family therapist >Lynn Hoffman puts it this way, "No one can change, grow, or leave the field >under a negative connotation" (Hoffman, 1981). In the same way, assertions >of inferiority about students of color may prevent them from achieving. >Furthermore, the assertion of the strengths or superiority of privileged >groups can become a social construct that maintains that sense of privilege. >For example, although Asian Americans, as a group, have a 15-point lead in >IQ scores compared to whites, and score higher than white students on >achievement >tests, we do not hear much reported anxiety about the "white achievement >gap." In fact, many educators do not even know that this >Asian-American-White gap exists. > >WHERE TEACHERS BELIEVE that they are teaching a highly capable group of >students, the students perform as such. > >Research on academic achievement is complex, and no single theory of >achievement entirely explains why some students succeed in school while >others do not. We do know from years of studies that expectations impact >profoundly on achievement. In independent schools, "higher level" and "lower >level" classes and calls to "work harder" may interfere with achievement >among black and Latino students and intensify stereotype threat. Treisman's >research at the University of California at Berkeley revealed that >"remedial" classes are not the solution to black and Latino achievement. > >WHERE TEACHERS BELIEVE that they have a less capable class, the students' >performance matches these lowered expectations. > >Many schools require underprepared or underachieving black and Latino >students to participate in remedial programs. Essentially, the intense >remediation of students of color sends the implicit message that they are >deficient (Ford, 1996; Speede-Franklin, 1988) and may deepen stereotype >threat. The striking success of Steele's 21st-century program at The >University of >Michigan, to which students are recruited honorifically, mixed with other >students of different ethnicities, and meet in study groups and rap groups, >is notable. > >WHAT VALUE DO BLACK AND LATINO STUDENTS BRING TO YOUR SCHOOL? > >The questions we ask often determine the answers, and looking for the >negative often reveals it. In our research, we asked the following question: >What do black and Latino students contribute to the environment at your >school? In business terms, what is the value added by having black and >Latino students as members of your academic community? > >We were told that blacks and Latinos brought a deeper sense of spirituality >and stronger family ties than do other students. Is this equally true in >other independent schools? Asking this question during our research was not >intended to create negative perceptions about other groups nor to idealize >students of color. As with academic ability, moral, spiritual, and family >values vary among individuals. Yet culture and context do matter. > >Why doesn't the moral accomplishment independent schools see in black and >Latino students get written about and celebrated? This is particularly >important because independent schools traditionally pride themselves on >character development. The Phillips Academy Constitution of 1778, for >example, states "goodness without knowledge is weak and feeble; yet >knowledge without goodness is dangerous." More recently, an emphasis has >also been placed on service in the public sphere (Independent School, Fall >2000). At the Winsor School in Boston, for example, "students are expected >to pursue academic and personal excellence and to show concern and respect >for others, for the community of the school, and for the world in which they >live." > >If, at your school, you were to stop and look at the school's mission, what >other dimensions of achievement would be implicit there? Does the mission >statement of your school speak to achievement of character development, >service to others, or the common good? If so, then you may be missing the >point by only measuring achievement in terms of grades. > >WHAT IN YOUR SCHOOL SUPPORTS A POSITIVE OUTCOME FOR ALL STUDENTS? > >Our own research at one independent school revealed no statistical >differences in the grade-point averages of black, white, Asian-American, and >Latino students. The most interesting and useful question that follows may >be: "What in that academic environment supports this positive outcome?" > >The literature on the "achievement gap" suggests that there is something >inherently problematic about being black or Latino that is the cause of poor >outcomes. What is often missing is the realization that achievement, like >any other behavior, is context dependent. It does not sit inside a student >like a fortune in a fortune cookie, foretelling a good or bad future. > >One way to avoid this trap is to ask: "What in the school context might be >telling students that they're not worth it?" Discussing achievement in The >Black-White Test Score Gap, Ron Ferguson of Harvard University writes: "My >bottom-line conclusion is that teachers' perceptions, expectations, and >behaviors probably do help to sustain, and perhaps even to expand, the >black-white test score gap." > >One major documented factor that impacts on student performance is the >Pygmalion Effect. It has been shown repeatedly that teachers' expectation of >their students dramatically affects student performance. Where teachers >believe that they are teaching a highly capable group of students, the >students perform as such. Where teachers believe that they have a less >capable class, the students' performance matches these lowered expectations. > >The power of positive connotation and possibility thinking are conveyed in a >story from the 2000 Summer Olympics in Australia: Eric M, a swimmer from >Equatorial Guinea, entered in the trials for the 100-meter freestyle. He >entered as what was called a "wild-card entry" by invitation of the Olympic >committee. These invitations were given to countries whose lack of resources >and economic development made it impossible to enter on their own. Because >the other two competitors in his heat jumped the gun and were eliminated, >Eric swam the race alone. He was described as swimming the race without >grace, without style, but with guts. He had been swimming for only nine >months when he entered the Olympics; this was the longest distance he'd ever >swum. Eric said, "I was thinking that I cannot finish the race, but when I >see a lot of persons applauding, I get power and I finish the race." His >time was one minute slower than the qualifier, but it was none-the-less >defined by the media as a winning time. "That's the spirit of the Olympics," >said one woman. "You don't have to be the fastest swimmer to be a hero >here." > >Rather than focusing on the "achievement gap," schools might better ask, >"What is the spirit of learning and the climate for learning in our school?" > >Attention to the five questions raised here can help independent schools >fulfill their missions and reveal the key importance of their place in the >American educational landscape. Grades, enrollment in challenging classes, >and achieving honors are important, when connected to an expanded definition >of achievement that recognizes character, value added, and the range of >positive outcomes that result from enrollment in independent schools. > >Patricia Romney is a psychologist consulting for equity and excellence in >independent schools. More information available at www.romneyassociates.com. > >Article can be found at : >http://www.nais.org/pubs/ismag.cfm?file_id=2677&ismag_id=30 > > >
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Thu Mar 11 2004 - 12:18:13 EST